5.22.2008

Update - Hague Convention on Choice of Court Agreements

The important Hague Convention on Choice of Court Agreements is now open for signature, ratification, and accession. For a discussion of the Convention and the process by which it advances toward its entry into force, click here.

Recently, the ABA's International Litigation Committee was in communication with the U.S. State Department's David Stewart, Assistant Legal Adviser for Private International Law in the Office of Legal Affairs, about the Convention and progress toward its ratification.

Mr. Stewart advised that the current focus is on issues regarding the Convention's implementation. The State Department, after its evaluation, forwards a memorandum to the President requesting authority to sign the desired convention. Before State forwards its signature memorandum as to this Convention, it requires a clear understanding as to how the Convention might be implemented. Mr. Stewart and his staff are working on the drafting of a tentative federal statute, but he states that considerable concern exists as to whether solely federalizing the issues addressed by the Convention is the optimum approach.

The National Conference on Commissioners on Uniform State Laws (NCCUSL) is actively evaluating how a uniform state law might be structured. A NCCUSL Drafting Committee, chaired by Idaho Uniform Law Commissioner, Rex Blackburn, is at work in that regard.

State will consider how NCCUSL's draft uniform state law and the draft federal statute might be integrated. That said, State expects to issue its signing memorandum shortly.

For more information about our international legal services, please contact us at +1.208.939.4472 or info@technologylawgroup.com or visit our Web site at http://www.technologylawgroup.com.

Hague Convention on Choice of Court Agreements - Backgrounder

The Hague Convention on Private International Law concluded the Hague Convention on Choice of Court Agreements in June 2005 after thirteen (13) years of negotiation. The goal of the Convention is to improve the ability to efficiently resolve disputes and enforce judgments in cross-border transactions. For a comprehensive text on the Convention and its commentary, please click here.

In terms familiar to those drafting contracts in common law countries like the United States, the Convention establishes conditions under which the parties may contractually agree to consent to exclusive personal jurisdiction in a particular state or federal court.

Late last fall, Mexico became the first state to accede to the Hague Convention on Choice of Court Agreements. The American Bar Association has urged that the United States adopt, ratify, and implement the Convention. See Background Note, infra.

The Convention sets forth the rules by which parties in different countries prospectively agree to resolve civil or commercial disputes in an agreed forum. Further, judgments in those agreed fora must be enforced by the courts in other countries adopting the Convention, provided exceptions do not apply.

The Convention sets forth a number of public policy exceptions to its applicability. Of importance to our intellectual property clients and constituencies, the Convention is not applicable to certain intellectual property matters. Specifically, the Convention does not govern in matters regarding the invalidity of intellectual property rights (excluding copyright and related rights) and regarding infringement of intellectual property rights that occur or could be brought under contract law (again, excluding copyright and related rights). See Articles 2 (2)(n)-(o) & 10(3).

For more information about the assistance we can provide in international transactional matters, please contact us at +1.208.939.4472 or info@technologylawgroup.com.

BACKGROUND NOTE: As the development of the positive international law (treaty law) goes, conventions, once concluded, are then opened for accession by states (countries), both members of the Hague Convention and non-members. Once agreed by the specified number of states, the Convention then enters into force. This process of adoption and implementation, that is, the incorporation of the treaty's principles into the domestic law, takes several years. Note, however, that treaties may become evidence of binding customary international law even without their entry into force. Generally and in addition, parties may opt in to the applicability of a treaty even if that treaty has not yet entered into force.

5.21.2008

Supreme Court Rules Emails Offering/Seeking Online Child Porn Not Protected Speech

The U.S. Supreme Court released its 7-2 ruling on Monday that people who send online messages seeking or offering sexual images of children are not engaging in speech protected under the First Amendment and so can be sent to prison. The Court's ruling applies even if there is no such underlying pornography.

Law enforcement officials praise the decision as enabling them to more efficiently combat criminal acts surrounding and depicting the sexual abuse of children. The decision is one of an ongoing judicial rulings on legislative attempts to balance free speech rights against the need to protect children from the rampant and insidious criminal activity.

For more information, see this report by David Savage in The Los Angeles Times. The Court's decision in United States v. Williams is available here.

For more information about Internet law-related matters, please contact us at info@technologylawgroup.com or +1.208.939.4472.

4.21.2008

More Disputes Going Before China's Courts

China News recently reported on new systems put in place by the Chinese courts to increase public awareness of complicated court proceedings and to expedite the resolution of disputes through the courts.

The article also reports some encouraging statistics that reflect on the rule of law in China. It cites a March 2008 State Supreme Court work report that China's courts handled almost 32 million cases from 2003 through 2007. That's up 1.6% over the previous four-year period (1998-2002).

The Shanghai courts saw a much larger increase in their case loads, however, which were up 10% during the same time period. This finding about the Shanghai courts is consistent with observations by my colleagues in the Licensing Executives Society and the American Bar Association's China Committee that courts in certain Chinese cities, Shanghai among them, are becoming more educated as to intellectual property rights and more reliable as fora for the resolution of intellectual property disputes.

To read the China News article, click here. For an excellent list of China resources compiled by the ABA's China Committee, click here.

For more information about doing business in China and with Chinese companies, please contact us at +1.208.939.4472 or info@technologylawgroup.com.

4.20.2008

Doing Business in China? Check Out This Recommended Reading!

Recently, the American Bar Association's China Committee discussed books on China that have been useful to our members and to our respective clients doing business in that country or planning to do so.

With more than 500 attorney members around the world, the China Committee is a joint body of the ABA's International Law, Intellectual Property Law, and Science and Technology practice sections.

The China Committee's recommended reading includes books covering topics ranging from China's place in the global economy to the consumer products market there to histories that elucidate Chinese cultural and business philosophies.

I have gathered these titles together for you here in the new Resources link. You'll find the link on the right side of this page above the blog archive listing. Click here and you'll go to our Amazon store to see all the China titles.

You will also see a collection of the TLG team's favorite resources on entrepreneurship, intellectual property strategy, women in science and technology, and more. Because we support Science Olympiad and other programs to foster children's creativity and natural interest in science and technology, we've even put together a set of excellent chemistry sets, books, and other great products to help Kids Create!

To discuss more about your business activities and plans in China, please contact us at +1.208.939.4472 or info@technologylawgroup.com.